A public service of The Hunterdon Scoop · Hunterdon County, New Jersey
The trade with the hardest sales tactics in home improvement. Know the game before the appointment. We checked what's checkable on every window contractor we could find serving the county. Every fact below names its source and the date we checked. Nobody paid to be on this page, and nobody can.
6 checked · 3 we'd call first
Flemington, Hunterdon County
Only in-county HQ (Flemington) with both a real address and a deep, consistent review count (5.0/5, 109 Google reviews) — call first for a baseline local quote. Credential verified against the state registry, date shown.
Lebanon, Hunterdon County
Second in-county HQ (Lebanon), longest local track record (24 years registered, family claims 40+), and the deepest review count found for any provider in this list (155 on authenticfeedback.com) — call for the long-track-record option, just verify the non-accredited BBB status doesn't bother you. Credential verified against the state registry, date shown.
Bridgewater, Somerset (adjacent, serves Hunterdon towns incl. Clinton, Frenchtown, Flemington) County
Longest operating history of any provider found (44 years) and BBB-accredited with a strong Google rating; caveat is they're Somerset County-based, ~25-30 min from central Hunterdon towns, not a walk-in-the-door local shop. Credential verified against the state registry, date shown.
We pull credentials from the official registries ourselves and print the date next to every status — window and door replacement is a Home Improvement Contractor (HIC) job under NJ's Contractor Registration Act — any job over $500 requires the contractor to be registered with the NJ Division of Consumer Affairs (registration numbers look like 13VH#######00). This is a registration (proof of $500k+ liability insurance, on file with the state) not a trade exam license — it does not certify installation skill. Verify status, expiration, and any discipline history at https://www.njconsumeraffairs.gov/hec/Pages/verification.aspx or https://newjersey.mylicense.com/verification/ before signing anything. A contractor operating without an active HIC registration on a job over $500 is breaking NJ law regardless of how good their sales pitch is.. Picks are editorial judgment on the checkable record: years in the trade, complaint patterns, review consistency, real presence in the county. No company paid to be listed, none can pay to become a pick, and when a pick has a weak spot we print it. Here are the full rules.
| Company & services | Based in | NJ HIC # | Registry status | BBB | Reviews (as reported) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bullseye Siding LLC (Bullseye Siding, Windows and Doors LLC) Registered as Bullseye Siding LLC Vinyl siding installation · Window replacement · Door replacement/installation | Flemington In county | 13VH07523000 | ✓ Active · 2026-07-14 | Not checked | 5.0 · 109 reviews (Google); 95.0 (BuildZoom score (out of 150 max, ranking metric not a star rating)) |
| Hunterdon Roofing, Siding & Window Company Registered as Hunterdon Siding & Window Co., LLC Window replacement (vinyl, wood, fiberglass) · Entry and patio door replacement · Roofing · Vinyl siding | Lebanon In county | 13VH00209500 | ✓ Active · 2026-07-14 | A+ | 4.9 · 155 reviews (Third-party review aggregator (authenticfeedback.com)); 4.6 (Houzz) |
| Markey Windows, Doors & More (James T. Markey Home Remodeling LLC) Registered as James T. Markey Home Remodeling LLC Window replacement · Door replacement · Siding · Roofing · Gutters | Bridgewater | 13VH00674000 | ✓ Active · 2026-07-14 | A+, accredited | 4.9 · 70 reviews (Google (per search summary)) |
| ACRE Windows and Doors Registered as Acre Replacement Windows (Horsham, PA entity; markets as ACRE Windows & Doors NJ) Andersen-brand window replacement · Entry and patio door replacement | Horsham, PA (serves NJ incl. Hunterdon towns via templated service pages) | PA010655 (PA license, confirmed on BBB); a secondary source reported a separate NJ HIC number as 13VH05350400 but this was NOT verified live against the NJ registry — confirm before hiring | … Pending check | Not checked | 4.8 · 309 reviews (BBB profile (self-reported)); 4.1 (HomeAdvisor) |
| Deegan Brothers Roofing & Siding Window replacement · Door installation · Roofing · Siding · Gutters | Phillipsburg | 13VH04755000 | ✓ Active · 2026-07-14 | Not checked, accredited | 285 reviews (Birdeye); 14 reviews (Yelp) |
| KLM Contractors (KLM Contractor Services LLC) Registered as KLM Contractor Services LLC Window and door replacement (per templated town page) · Siding · Decks · Stucco remediation | Avalon (Cape May County) — publishes a Frenchtown, NJ service page | 13VH07587100 | ✓ Active · 2026-07-14 | Not checked | 108.0 (BuildZoom score (ranking metric, not a star rating)) |
Registry status comes straight from the state's verification system on the date shown, and you can rerun any number there yourself in about two minutes. Review scores are what the named platforms report and we have not audited them. BBB grades as of July 2026. "Based in" is the registered address city, which sometimes differs from where a company says it operates. An active registration is the floor, not an endorsement; the picks we would actually call are above.
NJ statewide average window replacement runs roughly $450-$1,100 per window installed depending on material (vinyl low end, wood/fiberglass high end) and roughly $3,500-$9,000 for a whole-house door package; these are general NJ/regional contractor-site ranges, not Hunterdon-specific quotes — get 3 written bids before treating any number as real. (Sources: contractor and cost-guide sites cited in research; no single authoritative Hunterdon-specific cost survey was found, so this note is directional only.)
Do it in your browser: check any license · check your quote · the storm-chaser test
Usually yes if you're changing the size of the opening, altering a load-bearing header, or it's a full frame replacement rather than a pocket/insert replacement into the existing frame — check with your specific town's construction office (each Hunterdon municipality issues its own permits). A legit contractor will tell you up front whether your job needs one and should pull it, not leave it to you.
Often not. Several companies that show up heavily in Hunterdon-town searches (KLM Contractors, PJ Fitzpatrick, national brands like Renewal by Andersen) are headquartered an hour-plus away and run templated 'service area' pages for every town in the region — that's not disqualifying on its own, but it means less local accountability and no easy in-person office to walk into if something goes wrong. Ask directly where their crews are based and how many jobs they've done in your specific town.
It's a documented pattern in this trade, not a rare exception — NJ BBB complaints against multiple window/door companies cite same-day-signature pressure by name. A price that evaporates if you don't sign in the room is a sales tactic, not a real supply constraint; a contractor with a real backlog and real material costs can hold a quote for a few days while you get a second bid.
This page is run by The Hunterdon Scoop, the free email that covers what Hunterdon County actually talks about. Events, openings, and one contractor verified every week.